《天下收藏》栏目中王刚挥锤砸“真品”的质疑近日闹得沸沸扬扬，一些收藏人士认为，北京电视台这档栏目中被砸的瓷器有真品。为此，记者日前致电《天下收藏》栏目制片人韩勇，他表示，这些声音不会影响《天下收藏》栏目改变挥锤的方式，对于赝品，以后还会继续“砸”下去。8月21日，北京市文物局通过“北京发布”官方微博称：文物鉴定专家对《天下收藏》砸了的文物残品进行了鉴定，所有被砸文物都是假的。北京市文物局表示欢迎广大网民监督。

《The collection》The column with wang gang wave hammer hit“genuine”Of the questioned recently make an uproar，Some people think that collection，Beijing TV column of this file was hit of the porcelain have genuine。therefore，Reporters recently call《The collection》Column producer khoyama f，He said，The voice will not affect《The collection》Column change wave hammer way，For fake，It will continue“hit”down。August 21，By the Beijing municipal bureau of cultural relics“Beijing release”The official micro bo said：The cultural relics appraisal experts《The collection》Failed to identify substandard goods of cultural relics，All smashed cultural relics are false。The Beijing municipal bureau of cultural relics, welcomed the majority of Internet users to supervision。

　　当记者追问《天下收藏》栏目有哪些机制来保证不会砸掉真品时，该栏目制片人韩勇以现在不方便回答来回应。不过他重申，“我们拿的这些东西也不是什么疑难器物，对于鉴定结果，我们是完全可以负责任的。”

When a reporter asked《The collection》What are the column mechanism to ensure that won't hit off when genuine，This column producer khoyama f to now be inconvenient to answer to respond to。But he reiterated，“We take these things also not is what difficult artifacts，For the appraisal results，We are completely can be responsible。”

　　不过，更多业内人士分析，此类收藏节目实际上只能算娱乐节目，只是娱乐大众而已，这就不难解释为何不少人爆料其实这档节目是在潘家园买了假货，然后拿到电视上表演而已。韩勇认为，此种说法自相矛盾，“都这么说了，为什么还质疑我们砸碎的东西里有国宝呢？”韩勇最后解释，收藏节目展现的只是辨真假，不存在欺骗观众的问题，“如果做成纯收藏讲堂恐怕就没人看了”。

but，More of the personage inside course of study，Such collection programs in fact can only calculate entertainment，Just entertainment only，It would not be difficult to explain why many people kept in fact this program is in panjiayuan bought fake，Then get it on TV show。Khoyama f think，This kind of view self-contradiction，“Say so，Why also questioned the things we crack there is treasure？”Khoyama f finally explain，Collect program show is distinguishes the true and false，Does not exist the problem of cheat audience，“If make pure collection lecture hall I'm afraid nobody saw”。

　　与此同时，质疑方代表、收藏家姚政透露，一周内他们要去找电视台交涉，要求该节目停止“砸宝”行为。

meanwhile，Questioned party representative、Collectors YaoZheng revealed，A week they will find television bargaining，For the program to stop“Hit treasure”behavior。

　　(王雯淼)

(WangWenMiao)