《中国好声音》上周五晚一开播就火了，可谓一鸣惊人，也逆转了人们多年来对荧屏选秀的审美疲劳，然而，就在人们纷纷夸奖浙江卫视播出的这一全新歌唱类节目、连冯小刚、姚晨、李玟等众多名人也纷纷表达出对“好声音”的溢美之词时，网上一片质疑声也随之而起，其中最为激烈的就是质疑选手在舞台上大打煽情故事牌，批评节目依然没有逃脱“讲故事”的俗套，指责煽情如果有用，还要唱歌干吗？

《China good voice》Last Friday night thereafter will fire，Blockbuster is，Also reverse people for many years to screen the draft aesthetic fatigue，however，In people in succession of zhejiang TV broadcast of praise of a new singing kind of program、Even feng xiaogang、YaoChen、Coco lee and many other celebrities have to express“Good voice”When of word of，A flood of Internet misgivings about also has ensued，The most violent player on the stage is questioned a SOB story brand，Criticism is still not escape program“stories”Stereotypes of，Accused touchy-feely if useful，Also singing why？

　质疑故事煽情 Questioned SOB story

　　质疑声中首当其冲的就是感动了冯小刚、刘欢等人的真情女孩徐海星，她在演唱了一曲《自己》后，在与导师们交流互动时表示，自己当音乐老师的爸爸最喜欢的歌手就是刘欢，她前来参赛就是为了完成爸爸的心愿。导师刘欢问道：“你爸爸是否来到了现场?”徐海星说：“我觉得我爸爸来了。”这一下就把观众和评委一起带入真情故事，她缓缓地说出爸爸三个月前刚刚去世，本来觉得天已经塌了，没想到现在还可以站在这里完成爸爸的心愿。此刻，刘欢也被她感动得泣不成声，泪流满面。这一场面被不少网友评论为:“太催泪了”，一些网友甚至质疑“好声音”的选手们为煽情在造假，徐海星和农民歌手邹宏宇及开美甲店的黄勇等都被推到了风口浪尖，急得节目组连连辟谣澄清。

Misgivings about the brunt is moved feng xiaogang、Liu joyfully, etc XuHaiXing true girl，She was singing one song《oneself》after，In with mentors interaction said，His music teacher's dad when favorite singer is liu joyfully，She came to compete in order to complete the desire of the father is。Teacher liu joyfully asked：“If your father came to the scene?”XuHaiXing said：“I think my dad。”This audience and the judges together into love stories，She slowly tell dad has just died three months ago，I felt days has been flat，That now can stand here to complete the desire of the father。At this moment，Liu joyfully was also her moved to weeping bitterly，tearful。The scene was not a few net friend comment on:“Too tear the”，Some net PALS even questioned“Good voice”Players in for emotional to false，XuHaiXing and farmers ZouHongYu singer and open the salon HuangYongDeng are back to the outlet wave，Created a nasty rumor clarification。

　场面幸福温馨 Scene happy warmth

　　定于今晚播出的《中国好声音》，依然继续推出煽情故事。今年30岁的刘悦来自江苏，她以极强的冲击力完美演绎了《寂寞先生》，歌词寂寞，歌声更寂寞，她唱着唱着流泪了，她呜咽着说：“唱这首歌的时候，自己的经历像画面一般在回放。”四位导师对刘悦评价颇高，刘欢说：“要把感情融入歌声里需要能力；把感情融入的同时还能感动那么多人，更需要能力。你太有能力了！”来自天津的准妈妈齐雯深情地演唱了那英的经典歌曲《不管有多苦》：“不管与你的路有多苦，我只想要拥有最后的祝福。再多的伤害我都不在乎，愿你我挣脱一切的束缚……”这歌声酷似那英，连那英都感慨“太像了”。当四位导师知道唱歌的齐雯已怀有两个月的身孕时，竟一同登台放歌，用歌声为她和宝宝送去祝福，这一场面令人感到幸福温馨。

Is scheduled to be broadcast tonight《China good voice》，Still continue to release SOB story。This year at the age of 30 LiuYue from jiangsu，She with extremely strong impact perfect deduce《Mr Lonely》，The lyrics lonely，More lonely song，She sing for tears，She moan：“Sing this song，His experience as a replay general picture。”Four LiuYue mentor to highly，Liu joyfully said：“Let your heart into song need ability；The feelings of in the meantime also can move into so many people，Need more ability。You are too powerful！”From tianjin expectant mother JiWen deep feeling ground sang the song classics na ying《No matter how hard》：“No matter how much the way with you pain，I just want to have the final blessing。No amount of damage I don't care，Wish you to break free of all bound...”This song like na ying，Even the na ying are mixed“Too like the”。When four teacher about the singing JiWen already have two months pregnant，But on the stage with sings，For her baby in songs and send blessings，The scene was a happy warmth。

　　对于《中国好声音》中接连出现煽情故事，有网友指责，既然标榜的是“好声音”，那为何还要用故事来煽情，这无疑是自扇耳光?有网友说，这是不是反映了综艺选秀节目存在的“才艺不足，故事补救”的窘状？

for《China good voice》For appear in SOB story，Netizens accused，Since that is“Good voice”，That why still want to use to SOB story，This is undoubtedly the fan on the ear?Have net friend say，Does this reflect the reality TV variety of existence“Talent shortage，Story remedy”JiongZhuang of？

　　不妨反问一句 Might as well ask a

　　实际上，这些批评声、质疑声，都忽视了一个最根本的前提，即故事煽情帮不了学员。因为，担任导师的刘欢、那英、庾澄庆和杨坤听歌时，都背对学员在“盲选”，此刻，好声音是选择关键。当导师们转过身面对学员时，选择早已作出，故事再煽情也改变不了导师们的决定。才艺不足，故事煽情于事无补。

In fact，These critical、Misgivings about，All neglect the most fundamental premise，That is sensational story can help students。because，As the teacher liu joyfully、Na ying、YuChengQing and YangKun to listen to，All students back in“Blind choose”，At this moment，Good sound is to choose the key。When the teacher turned face when students，Choose to have，SOB story again will change the decision of the mentors。Talent shortage，SOB story no use。

　　有网友质问，说煽情如果有用，还要唱歌干吗？答案应该是这样的，真情故事当然有用，这有助于让我们更加了解和亲近一个个有血有肉有感情的年轻学员，也有助于提升观众观看这一节目的兴趣，更有助于体现出引起社会强烈反响的人文关怀和价值追求。《中国好声音》刚开播收视就出现飘红，这就是最好的证明。否则，备受观众称赞的“正能量”、“太激动”、“太意外”、“太美好”等真情感受，都会变得荡然无存。如果没有了这些真情故事，仅剩下一首首歌曲，即便唱得再好，观众依然会索然无味，这一点，可从央视今年停办青歌赛中得到佐证。面对如此质疑声浪，人们不妨反问一句，好声音加上好故事，有什么不可以？

Netizens questioned，Sensational said if useful，Also singing why？The answer should be like this，Love stories of course useful，This will help make us more understanding and close to flesh out one of the young students have feelings，Also helps to improve the program audiences to watch the interest，The more help to reflect cause social strong reaction of the humanities concern and value pursuit。《China good voice》Just ratings appear broadcasting turn red，This is the best proof。otherwise，The audience is praise“Positive energy”、“Too excited”、“Too accident”、“Too good”True feelings such as，Will become disappeared。If not the love stories，Left songs sound installation，Even sing better，The audience will still vapid，this，But this year QingGeSai suspension from CCTV had echoes。Faced with that question movements，People might as well ask a，Good sound and good stories，Have what not？

　　首席记者 俞亮鑫

YuLiangXin chief correspondent