北京电视台的“天下收藏”并不以收藏品的惊人价值吸引观众的眼球，而是注重藏品的真假鉴定。节目中，著名表演艺术家、主持人王刚有一把紫金锤，如果经在场专家鉴定持宝人的瓷器为假，在双方签署完协议后，他会挥起紫金锤将“赝品”砸碎。著名收藏家、中国收藏家协会玉器委员会主任姚政等反复观看展览后称，该栏目“所砸掉的‘赝品’不少是真品，并且不乏珍品”。

Beijing TV“The collection”Not to the collection of amazing value to attract people's eyeballs，But pay attention to collection of true and false of the appraisal。program，Famous performing artists、The host WangGangYou a zijin hammer，If the present expert evaluation the treasure of China to false，In the agreement signed by both parties，He'll wield zijin hammer will“fake”smashed。Famous collector、Chinese collector association jade committee director, such as YaoZheng repeatedly exhibition hereafter，This section“Have hit off‘fake’Many is genuine，And there is no lack of treasures”。

　　就算是被砸碎的是所谓的“赝品”，藏品，不仅是文物，也是草根基层旺盛的藏宝热情，以及对典藏文化的淳朴热爱。经济条件好了，更多人愿意将兴趣和资金，投向藏宝、收藏，通过收藏，释放对博大精深的传统文化的敬仰和膜拜，让更多源远流长的文化典籍、宝贵文物得到保护。中国近些年收藏文化不断发展，与这种草根推动，关系密切。

It is through what is called“fake”，collection，Is not only a cultural relics，Also grassroots grassroots exuberant buried treasure enthusiasm，As well as to the collection of the culture of the simple love。Economic conditions well，More people are willing to interest and capital，Treasure to、collection，Through the collection，Release the profound traditional culture of respect and worship，Let more cultural classics has a long history、Precious cultural relics be protected。China collection culture development in recent years，And this kind of grassroots push，close。

　　现在，因为藏品有“问题”就一锤子打碎，打碎的是文物，也砸碎了收藏人的热忱爱戴。毕竟，每一个藏品对于收藏人而言，都有一段与众不同的特殊感情、精神历程，公共文化平台应该最大化尊重和保护这种文化感受、朴素的文化真情。单单过分强调藏品的真伪和经济价值，而对于其中透射出的人文内涵、与众不同的把玩、玩味，视而不见，谁说不是一种粗鲁简单的文化愚蠢呢？

now，Because collection have“problems”A broken hammer，Break is cultural relics，Also smashed collect people's enthusiasm love。After all，Each collection to collect people，Have a distinctive special feelings、Spirit course，Public cultural platform should maximize respect for and protection of the cultural experience、Simple culture indeed。Only emphasize the collection of authenticity and economic value，For the transmission of the humanities connotation、Different play、ponder，Turn a blind eye to，Who said not a rude simple culture stupid？

　　对民间藏品过于粗暴还造成了文物的大量外流。“这些年，在新加坡、马来西亚，还有中国的香港、台湾等地区，见到许多这样流出去的瓷器，都非常的好。而且，他们收的价钱还很低，人家说：‘这些都是你们不要的。’”中国国家博物馆原中国文物交流中心主任雷从云告诉记者，就他所研究的元青花瓷器而言，民间的力量确实“不容小觑”。所以说鉴宝过程不够精心、不够慎重、不够科学、缺乏稳妥，还会影响中国文物发展的安全和公信力，也非虚妄。

The folk collection too rough also caused a large number of outflow cultural relic。“these，In Singapore、Malaysia，And China's Hong Kong、Taiwan and other regions，See so many outflow to China，Are very good。and，They accept the price is still very low，The somebody else say：‘These are you don't。’”Chinese country museum original China cultural heritage exchange center director ray from cloud told reporters，He had the yuan blue and white porcelain in research，Folk power is indeed“Not allow small gaze”。So treasure evaluation process carefully enough、Not careful、Not enough scientific、Lack of safety，Can also affect the development of Chinese cultural relics safety and credibility，Nor false。

　　况且从鉴别的程序上来说，就算是鉴别者是权威专家，也难免会有“眼花”的时候，谁能保证鉴别真的就能“万无一失”呢？正如有藏品被砸的收藏者提出的质疑，“我到今天都认为我的瓷器没问题。瓷片我还留着呢，有机会我会去牛津大学做权威鉴定。”“瓷器被砸后，拿着碎瓷片到很多机构做过科学鉴定，结论证明这瓷器是‘对’的”。

Moreover from the identification program speaking，Even identify are authoritative experts，Also hard to avoid can have“giddy”when，Who can guarantee that identify really can“No risk at all”?？As a collection of collectors smashed the question，“I thought my today's China no problem。Ceramics I still have it with me，There is a chance that I will go to Oxford University authority appraisal。”“Porcelain be hit after，With a broken plaques that many agencies do scientific appraisal，Conclusion prove this porcelain is‘to’of”。

　　任何口头承诺都是靠不住的，真正的鉴别，还是应该有一个科学、稳定、规范的程序，而不是少数专家说了算。否则，就是一种草率了！中国社会科学院考古研究所李健民研究员说，“对这些民间收藏最大的抢救和保护，就是对它们认可，先别忙着否定、忙着砸掉它们，安下心来好好研究，必要的时候引入科学鉴定。”是很有道理的。

Any verbal commitment are unreliable，The real identification，Or should have a science、stable、Standard program，Not a few experts have the final say。otherwise，Is a kind of hasty！The Chinese academy of social sciences institute of archaeology LiJianMin researchers say，“These folk collection to the largest rescue and protection，Is the recognized them，Don't get busy negative、Busy to hit them off，Get down to study，Necessary introduce scientific appraisal。”It is quite reasonable。

　　高高举起的“鉴宝锤”还是慢慢放下来吧，多听听公众对科学鉴宝机制的呼唤，多尊重公众对民间鉴宝的热情，多对民间藏宝人多一些尊重和善待，这才是最应该采取的方略，而绝对不是“一锤子打碎”。

Held high the“Treasure evaluation hammer”Or slowly down it，Listen to the public scientific treasure evaluation mechanism call，More respect for the public to folk treasure evaluation enthusiasm，Many of the folk buried treasure some respect and treat，This is the most should take the strategy，And certainly not“A hammer broken”。

　　耿银平

GengYinPing