据经济之声《天天315》报道，大家都出门旅行过，出门旅行的人都喜欢给自己的亲朋好友带一些当地的纪念品。大家都是善良的，当碰到一个阔商，因为自己96岁的爷爷卧病在床，要散财为爷爷祈福的时候，你会怎么做呢？侯女士在海南琼海碰到这样的事后所发生的故事。

According to the sound of economic《Every day 315》report，We all go on a journey，A trip to people like his relatives and friends take some local souvenirs。Everybody is kind，When run into a rich merchant，Because her 96-year-old grandfather is ill in bed，To spread your wealth for grandpa prayers，What would you do？A lady in hainan qionghai run into so of the story of what happened afterwards。

亲历者说 Invaluable said

玉石店老板以祈福之名“忽悠”游客 Jade in the name of the shopkeeper praying“suddenly”tourists

　　侯女士：我家是四个姐弟都是退休的人了，我们就相约就报团到海南去旅游。6月26日下午，随团从三亚返程路过琼海市的时候，导游就把我们带到一家玉石店，就是琼海市银海路一家酒店一楼的珠宝店。那个店面看上去还挺正规的，进门正中放着很大的貔貅的玉石。随后就来了一个叫林建升的老总，他匆匆忙忙的赶过来，说他刚刚从他爷爷96岁生日的宴会上面赶过来，亲自来接待我们这一批幸运的游客，接着就标榜他自己是全国十大杰出青年，又做过很多很多的善举，他说爷爷现在正在躺在医院的病床上面，为了尽孝道他说经过高人指点，要求他今天必须要布施一些钱财给有一面之交的朋友，让大家为爷爷祈福。

A lady：My house is four off.that's retirement，We will meet will report to go to hainan tourism group。June 26, afternoon，Traveling with a group from sanya return pass by QiongHaiShi，The tour guide us to our a jade store，Is QiongHaiShi silver sea road a jewelry store the first floor of the hotel。The store looks is quite normal，The center of the door put a lot of the mythical wild animal jade。Then came a call LinJianSheng of managers，He hurriedly come out，Said he just from his grandfather is 96 years old birthday party above come out，Personally to receive a batch of lucky we the tourists，Then he himself is the "ten outstanding young，And done a lot of a lot of good deeds，He said grandpa is now lying in a hospital bed above，In order to do filial piety he said after tall person to give directions，Ask him to sacrifice some money today to have YiMianZhiJiao friends，Let everybody prays for grandpa。

　　然后他先是拿一个小小的配件，说这个作为礼品送给大家。另外还指着台面上面一个红宝石项链和一个貔貅的玉石，说这两样东西刚好价值一万元，今天他不卖，全部赠送给我们，他说只要每个人给爷爷300元，买一个生日蛋糕，并且给爷爷写上一句祈福的话，留下联系电话，这一万元的宝石和项链就送给大家。

Then he first took a small parts，Said the as gifts gave everyone。In addition also pointed to a ruby necklace on mesa and a jade the mythical wild animal，Said the two things just value ten thousand yuan，Today he doesn't sell，All presented to us，He said that as long as everybody to grandpa 300 yuan，Buy a birthday cake，And to grandpa write his word blessing word，Leave your contact number，This ten thousand yuan of precious stones and necklace is gave everyone。

　　随后他又指着他柜台里面的其他一些玉石，对那些售货员说，今天全部不许卖，全部赠送，只要收税款就可以了。

He then and as he counter inside the other some jade，For those who said the salesman，Today all forbid to sell，Giving all，As long as the taxes。

　　他就拿出一个玉手镯，标价是22万8。他说你们今天只要给我1800的税款就可以了，国家的税不能少，其他的就不收了，货款不收。

He took out a jade bracelet, too，The list price is 220000 8。He said you today as long as give me 1800 taxes，National tax cannot little，The other won't charge，Don't accept payment。

　　我们大家出去玩嘛，看他表演得也非常真实，就每个人都选了一个，付了1800块钱税款。后来我们姐弟四个人一共就被他收了15400多块钱。

We all go out to play，Watching his performances have to also is very real，Is everyone chose a，Pay the $1800 tax。Then we asked four people have is that he accepted more than 15400 dollars。

　　以为自己买到便宜货的侯女士还相信林建升是在散财为爷爷祈福，她每天还给林建升就下的手机号发送祝福的话，希望林建升的爷爷早日康复。等回到自己家，在孩子的提醒之下，侯阿姨才意识到，自己可能上当了。

Think oneself buy steals a lady also believe in LinJianSheng is spread your wealth for grandpa peace，Every day she LinJianSheng went down to the phone, send good wishes，Hope LinJianSheng grandfather recover soon。Back into his own family，In the child's remind under，Hou aunt didn't realize，You might fall into trap。

　　侯阿姨：后来我们回来了，我儿子他们就上网去查，结果发现网上早就有人爆料，今年3月份就在一家叫做琼海嘉积乔城商场里面，也是爷爷生日、病在床，请大家为他买生日蛋糕祈福，乎是同样的骗术骗了很多消费者，很多人在投诉这个事情，我们就知道上当了。

Hou aunt：Later we came back，My son they go online to check，The results found online has already been kept，In march this year in a called qionghai jia product QiaoCheng bazaar inside，Is grandpa birthday、Sick in bed，Please buy birthday cake for his blessing，Who is the same legerdemain fooled a lot of consumers，Many people complain about the this things，We will know that fooled。

管理者说 Managers said

玉石店营业执照合法 这件事还需调查 Jade store business license legitimate it still need to survey

　　按照侯女士提供的玉器店老板林建升的电话，我们试图和孝顺的林老板取得联系，但是两个电话号码都一直无人接听。

According to a lady of jade shopkeeper LinJianSheng provide the phone，We tried to and filial piety the lam boss get in touch，But the two phone number are always went unanswered。

　　随后，记者与海南省琼海市工商局取得联系。在我详细的介绍了侯阿姨的受骗经过之后，琼海市工商局这位负责消费者投诉的吴姓工作人员告诉我们，这件事需要调查。

then，Journalists and hainan province contact QiongHaiShi industrial and commercial bureau。In my detailed introduces the hou aunt after fraud after，QiongHaiShi industrial and commercial bureau is responsible for the consumer complaints WuXing workers told us，It needs to survey。

　　工作人员：这个乔城原来是有一家，但是后来把这个乔城已经取缔了，据我所知。

staff：The QiaoCheng originally is a，But then the QiaoCheng has banned，As far as I know。

　　记者：乔城这个是没有了，但是他们现在又换到了一个琼海市银海路维佳酒店一楼叫做玉翔源珠宝店。

reporter：This is not QiaoCheng......，But now they change again to a QiongHaiShi silver sea road d better the first floor of the hotel called jade cheung source jewelry store。

　　工作人员：这个有，但是这个是有营业执照的。

staff：This has，But this is a business license。

　　记者：他是有营业执照，他怎么会有这样的营业执照的呢？他干的不是正经的生意啊。

reporter：He is a business license，How could he have such business license？He did not earnest business ah。

　　工作人员：营业执照是受法律保护的。你讲的这个东西，买的这个东西真跟假必须要有一个检验报告。营业执照是咱们工商部门发给他的，但是你现在投诉买的假的，具体我们还要就是说你买的假的，必须还要通过有关技术监督局国家法定机构检测出来确实是假的，不是你当事人说假就假。

staff：The business license is protected by law。You speak of this thing，Buy this thing really with false must have an inspection report。The business license is let's ministry of commerce and industry to him，But now you buy the false complaints，We also means you buy specific the false，Must also through the relevant technical supervision bureau of national legal institutions detected really is false，Not you say false is the false。

　　经济之声特约评论员包华也认为，目前还不能说是假货，还要鉴定机构鉴定。

The voice of the economy contracted commentators BaoHua also think，It was not, fake，Also appraisal organization identification。

　　包华：目前还不能说是假的。玉石有很多种，由于它的存量以及美观度不同，所以市场上的定价差异非常的巨大。在这种情况之下，我们不能说这个玉石就是假的，而只能说这个玉石器具跟老板开始标称的或者标价不相符合。

BaoHua：It was not untrue。Jade has a lot of kinds，Because of its stock and beautiful different degrees，So the market price of the difference is very great。In this situation，We can't say this jade is false，And can only say this jade utensils with the boss of the nominal price or start is not consistent with。

　　另外一个，我也赞同这个观点，就是说对于玉石是哪一类玉石，要进行鉴定，如果鉴定出来的结论跟标牌上所列明的品种不一样，可以认为是假的。但如果说标牌上写的这个类型就不是很清楚，那么这种情况之下很难说真与假，只能说贵与贱。

another，I also agree with this view，That is what kind of jade jade is for，To identify，If appraisal comes out with the conclusions of the sign of the varieties listed，Can think is false。But if the sign of this type is writing is not very clear，So this situation hard to say true and false，Can only say your and mean。

律师说 Lawyers say

玉石店老板的售卖方式涉嫌欺诈 Jade shopkeeper sales way alleged fraud

　　对于玉石店老板的这种售卖方式，北京岳成律师事务所律师宋俊彦认为，已经涉嫌欺骗。

For the sale of jade shopkeeper way，YueCheng Beijing lawyer of SongJunYan think，Is alleged fraud。

　　宋俊彦：这种售卖的方式像包华评论员所说的脱离了交易的本身，可能他打一个亲情牌，在做一个善举或者怎么样，博取大家的同情心，脱离了交易的实质。我觉得是欺诈，不管是编什么故事，他的目的是要实现这个交易，相当于编故事是他的一个手段，还是没有让消费者真实的了解到产品的客观信息，所以我觉得他这种行为是欺诈。因为标价是22万，最终售出是1800，这个就有差距。

SongJunYan：This way BaoHua commentators like sold said of the deal itself out，May he hit a family card，Doing a good deeds or，From all of compassion，From the essence of the transactions。I think that is fraud，Either make up what story，His aim is to realize the deal，Equivalent to make up the story is one of his means，Still no let consumers true understanding of the objective to product information，So I think he this behavior is fraud。Because the list price is 220000，Eventually sold is 1800，This is the gap。

专家说 Experts say

如此骗术屡禁不绝 原因是审查不严处罚不够 So LvJinBuJue legerdemain reason is examine lax punishment enough

　　对于为何如此骗术总是屡禁不止、死灰复燃，为什么？经济之声特约评论员包华认为还是处罚力度不够。

For why so legerdemain always long-standing、resurgent，why？The voice of the economy contracted commentators BaoHua think punishment is not enough。

　　包华：我认为有两个方面的原因。第一个，市场准入门槛提得不够高，也就是骗子可以用同样的方式，以同样的经营的特点反复的去开店，反复的去做经营，这就说明我们市场进入的门槛现在出现了一些疏漏或者说出现了一些审查不严的情况，而这些内容其实工商机关是有责任的。

BaoHua：I think there are two reasons。The first，Market admittance threshold propose isn't high enough，Also is the liar can use the same way，In the same business characteristics of repeatedly to open a shop，Repeated to do business，This means that we market entry threshold there are omissions or appeared some examine lax，And these content actually industry and commerce authority is responsible。

　　第二个在于处罚的力度，也就是说原来已经行骗的那家店，我们进行处罚的时候让他有能力继续再做这样的事情或者说继续再这样去做，说明当时的处罚的行为对其不伤筋不动骨。而且对其个人来说其，实没有追究具体的行为，可能更多的是经济性的处罚，对于行为人来说没有一个必要的约束。在这种情况之下，我认为是处罚力度不到位的体现。

The second is the strength of the punishment，That is the original has been deceiving the shop，We punishment of time for his ability to continue to do such a thing again or continue to do this，At the time of the behavior of the punishment that in its do not hurt the muscle fixed bone。And the person to its，No specific behavior for real，More likely, is of the punishment of the economy，For there is a necessary actor constraints。In this situation，I think that is the embodiment of the punishment does not reach the designated position。