华声在线1月23日讯(记者 罗浩)日前，湖南张家界、江西庐江和黑龙江五大连池三大景区，因在“向公众科普地球知识”等方面有所不足，被联合国教科文组织给予黄牌警告。随后，三大景区遭众多媒体和网友批评。1月21日，张家界市委外宣办主任王建军连发微博，称联合国教科文组织针对张家界的评估决定有诸多不合理之处，张家界不但不应被黄牌警告，而应该受到金牌奖励。

Hua sheng electronic online on January 23,)(Reporter LuoHao)a,Zhangjiajie in hunan/Jiangxi LuJiang and heilongjiang five dalian ChiSanDa scenic spot,Because in the"Popular science knowledge to the public the earth"Etc is insufficient,By the United Nations educational, scientific and cultural organization give booked.then,Three big scenic spot by many media criticism and net friend.January 21,,Zhangjiajie municipal party committee propaganda bureaus and foreign affairs offices director WangJianJun even FaWei bo,Says the United Nations educational, scientific and cultural organization in zhangjiajie evaluation decision have many shortcomings,Not only zhangjiajie should not be booked,And should be gold medal.

质疑一：几乎看不见世界地质公园的Logo? Questioned a:Almost can't see the world geological park Logo?

　　1月9日，中国世界地质公园年会在广东韶关举行。会上，联合国教科文组织公布了针对全球世界地质公园的评估决定报告，湖南张家界被给予黄牌警告，其世界地质公园身份的有效期由正常的四年缩短为两年。两年后张家界地质公园将被全面评估检查，如果张家界未能取得卓有成效的进步，将从世界地质公园网络中除名。

On January 9,,China's world geological park conference held in guangdong shaoguan.meeting,The United Nations educational, scientific and cultural organization announced the global world geological park assessment decided to report,Zhangjiajie in hunan were given booked,The world geological park the validity of identity by normal four years shorten for two years.Two years later, zhangjiajie geological park will be comprehensive evaluation and testing,If zhangjiajie failed to qualify for the effective progress,From the world geological park network clearly.

　　在这份评估决定报告中，联合国教科文组织针对张家界提出了十点改进建议。其中第一点指出，张家界“整个公园的铭文只注重宣传你们被列入世界自然遗产名录的情况”，“几乎看不到世界地质公园logo或用其他形式展现出的情形”。

In this assessment decided to report,The United Nations educational, scientific and cultural organization in zhangjiajie puts forward improvement Suggestions at ten o 'clock.The first point,zhangjiajie"The whole park only pay attention to the propaganda you have been listed as one of the world natural heritage list situation","Almost can't see the world geological park logo or in other forms show case".

　　针对这一点，王建军提出了强烈的质疑。王建军称，张家界自从被联合国列为首批世界地质公园后，张家界市委、市政府将“世界地质公园”的荣誉摆在与“世界自然遗产”同等重要的地位，在武陵源景区的大门、主要游客集散地、以及主要游道都设置了“世界地质公园”的Logo或者标识，与“世界自然遗产”并列进行宣传。整个景区关于“世界地质公园”的标识或者Logo在数十处以上。

In response to this,WangJianJun puts forward strongly questioned.WangJianJun says,Since the first zhangjiajie by the United Nations as the world geological park,Zhangjiajie municipal party committee/The municipal government will"The world geological park"Honor and set"The world natural heritage"Equally important position,Wulingyuan scenic spot in the door/The main tourist base/And the main tourism channel is set up"The world geological park"Logo or Logo,and"The world natural heritage"Coordinate propagandize.The entire scenic area about"The world geological park"Logo Logo or decades or more places.

　　王建军还称，在历次重大对外经贸和旅游活动、对外文化交流活动中，张家界市委、市政府都将“世界地质公园”的荣誉作为向国内外各届人士以及媒体记者推介的重点内容，并出版了多种外宣品宣传张家界世界地质公园。

WangJianJun also said,In all major foreign trade and tourism activities/Foreign cultural exchange activities,Zhangjiajie municipal party committee/The municipal government will"The world geological park"As to the honor of the domestic and foreign various people and media to promote the key content,And published many WaiXuan product publicity zhangjiajie world geological park.

　质疑二：向公众科普地球知识不足? Query two:The lack of science to the public knowledge?

　　针对日前多家媒体报道张家界“向公众科普地球知识不足”的问题，王建军在微博中也做了回应。

According to several media reports before zhangjiajie"The lack of science to the public knowledge"problem,WangJianJun in micro bo also responded.

　　王建军举例说，2010年11月，张家界邀请了包括国际地貌学家协会主席迈克尔·克罗泽在内的来自新西兰、英国、美国、德国等7个国家的16位国外地貌学权威专家学者，以及中国科学院院士李廷栋、刘嘉麒等国内20多位知名地质地貌学专家，在张家界召开“国际地貌学术研讨会”。

WangJianJun for example,In November 2010,Zhangjiajie invited including international geomorphology home association chairman Michael miroslav klose, from New Zealand/British/The United States/Seven countries such as Germany 16 foreign geomorphology authoritative experts and scholars,And LiTingDong academician of the Chinese academy of sciences/LiuJia jiaqi domestic more than twenty famous geological geomorphology experts,Held in zhangjiajie"International academic seminar on landscape".

　　在本次会议上，“张家界地貌”获得36位中外知名地质地貌学专家的一致认定。王建军说，这项在国际地质地貌学界具有重要意义的研讨会，是张家界对外宣传地球科学知识的重要创举，不仅是对“世界地质公园”地质地貌科学知识最好的诠释，还是对人类的巨大贡献。

In this meeting,"Zhangjiajie landform"Gain and a well-known Chinese and foreign geological geomorphology expert's consistent recognition.WangJianJun said,The geological and topographical features in the international academic seminar has important significance,Zhangjiajie is publicity earth science knowledge important creation,Not only for"The world geological park"Geological features of the best interpretation of scientific knowledge,Or to the human great contribution.

　　他认为，从这层意义上说，张家界在“向公众科普地球科学知识”方面，不仅不能受到联合国教科文组织的“黄牌警告”，反而应该受到“金牌奖励”。

He thinks,In this layer sense,Zhangjiajie in the"To the public dissemination of scientific knowledge of the earth"aspects,Not only by the United Nations educational, scientific and cultural organization"booked",But should be"Gold medal".

质疑三：评估的标准是什么? Query three:Evaluation standard is???????

　　在21日发布的长微博中，王建军对联合国教科文组织《关于张家界世界地质公园2012年评估决定》的评估标准提出了质疑。

In the 21 released in long micro bo,WangJianJun to the United Nations educational, scientific and cultural organization[About zhangjiajie world geological park of 2012 assessment decision]The criteria for the assessment of questioned.

　　根据王建军的说法，《关于张家界世界地质公园2012年评估决定》由世界地质公园网络评估局派出的两名地质专家所撰写。这两名专家在撰写评估决定报告前，曾前往张家界武陵源景区进行了为期2天的考察。王建军认为“短短两天的观察，对张家界市政府及相关部门做的工作，来不及全面地了解”。

According to the WangJianJun said,[About zhangjiajie world geological park of 2012 assessment decision]The world geological park network assessment agency sent two written geological experts.The two experts in writing assessment decision before the report,Had to zhangjiajie wulingyuan scenic spot for two days of study.WangJianJun think"Just two days of observation,To the zhangjiajie city government and related departments to do the job,Too late to fully understand".

　　他认为评估决定报告“几乎看不出科学的评估标准”， 仅仅是一些“加强合作”、“更多更好”等模糊概念。此外，评估决定报告中提及的“只注重宣传你们被列入世界自然遗产名录的情况”，带有“妒忌”成分。

He thinks to evaluation report"Almost can not see the scientific evaluation criteria", Are only some of the"Strengthen cooperation"/"More and better"Fuzzy concepts such as.In addition,To evaluate the report mentioned"Only pay attention to publicize your was listed as a world natural heritage list situation",with"envy"composition.

质疑四：中国媒体应该仰洋大人鼻息吗? Query four:The Chinese media should be elevated the adult harrumph?

　　炮轰联合国教科文组织之后，王建军还对国内媒体“一拥而上”的批评报道提出了自己的质疑。王建军称，报道张家界被亮黄牌的新闻很多，但到张家界进行实地采访的仅有中央电视台记者，“但最后在中央电视台报道出去的内容却与其它媒体一样，没有自己客观的声音”。

After the United Nations educational, scientific and cultural organization grins,WangJianJun of domestic media"Rush forward"Criticism report puts forward his own question.WangJianJun says,Zhangjiajie is bright yellow card reported the news a lot,But to zhangjiajie field interview with only the central TV reporter,"But in the end in the central television reported out content but with other media,No objective voice".

　　王建军认为，绝大多数媒体没有探究“世界地质公园网络评估局的评估标准是否合理”、“评估过程是否信息不对称”、“ 评估依据的标准是什么”、“三大景区虽有欠缺、是否有好经验?”等方面的新闻事实。

WangJianJun think,The vast majority of the media didn't explore"The world geological park of network evaluation criteria for the assessment of whether reasonable"/"Evaluation process is information asymmetry"/" Based on the evaluation standard is??????"/"Although there are three major scenic area lack/If there is a good experience?"The news fact, etc.

　　“中国媒体没有自己观点和看法，仰洋人鼻息、听到‘黄牌’马上认错自责的做法，只能让外国媒体看不起。”王建军在微博中如此写道。

"The Chinese media without their views and opinions,Overhead foreigner harrumph/hear‘Yellow card’Immediately apologize to the practice of era,Can only let the foreign media look down on."WangJianJun in micro bo such wrote.

　　网友：态度褒贬不一 Net friend:Attitude mixed

　　虽然王建军在微博中不断强调自己是个人意见，与供职单位无关，但并非所有网友都买账。有网友称，王建军的反驳“明显有为管理单位辩护的意味，如果真的没错，为何张家界官方那么快就承认错误并保证整改?”

Although WangJianJun in micro bo has stressed he is personal opinion,And not for the unit,But not all people buy it.Have net friend say,WangJianJun retort"For management unit obviously defend the means,If really right,Why zhangjiajie official so fast is to admit a mistake and ensure that corrective?"

　　还有网友以自身前往张家界的旅游经历佐证张家界“地质科普做得差”。该网友称，普通游客了解旅游景区信息的途径大多依靠导游的讲解，但导游大多着重讲述张家界的神话轶事，压根与地质地貌无关。

Have net friend to their own to zhangjiajie tourism experience of zhangjiajie"Geological science worse".The net friend said,Ordinary visitors understand tourism scenic area information way mostly rely on the tour guide's explanation,But most of the emphasis on zhangjiajie guide the myth of the anecdote,Has nothing to do with the geological features at all.

　　但也有网友认为，联合国教科文组织报告的出台确实仓促，存在一些不合理之处，“张家界的官员敢于质疑，是一件好事。质疑也是一种沟通，这有利于双方的互相认可，也有利于张家界世界地质公园的长远发展”。

But there are also net friend think,The United Nations educational, scientific and cultural organization report really rush,There are some shortcomings,"Zhangjiajie officials question,Is a good thing.Question is also a kind of communication,It is conducive to both sides of the mutual recognition,Zhangjiajie is also conducive to the long-term development of the world geological park".

　链接：张家界已从多方面着手整改 link:From zhangjiajie has many aspects to rectification

　　日前，张家界市国土资源局局长高建国接受采访时表示，张家界世界地质公园这块金字招牌来之不易，作为世界各地质公园网络成员，加强世界地质公园的建设管理与维护利用是不可推卸的责任和义务。此次黄牌警告表明了张家界在宣传科普知识方面仍然存在差距，亟待进一步完善。张家界将积极整改，针对在设立标识标牌、建立博物馆等方面工作存在的不足，把工作落实到位。

a,Zhangjiajie land and resources bureau chief GaoJianGuo an interview said,Zhangjiajie world geological park the gold-lettered signboard don't come easy,As the world geological park network members,Strengthen the construction of the world geological park management and maintenance use is an unshirkable responsibility and obligation.The yellow card shows that the zhangjiajie in the popular science knowledge propaganda in gap still exists,To further improve.Zhangjiajie will actively rectification,Based on the establishment of identification plate/Establishment of a museum work deficiency, etc,The work put in place.

　　目前，张家界国土资源局已经从世界地质公园的Logo更新、科普教材的通俗化编印、环境教育项目开展、溶洞环境保护、加大导游培训等十个方面提出了初步的整改规划，并成立了专门班子，着手拟定《张家界世界地质公园两年改进实施工作方案》，然后组织全面实施。

At present,Zhangjiajie bureau of land and resources has from the world geological park Logo update/Science popularization teaching material)/Environmental education programs/Cave environment protection/Increase the guide training ten aspects put forward the preliminary corrective plan,And has established the special group,Worked to[Zhangjiajie world geological park two years to improve implementation scheme],Then the full implementation of the organization.