华龙网7月13日22时讯（见习记者 肖子琦 记者 康延芳）学好地理是为了什么？丰富知识？便于旅游？这些答案都弱爆了！12日晚，网友“猥仙”在微博上发布了一张初中地理试卷的题目截图，截止13日23时竟引来600余网友转发，网友们转发之余纷纷调侃，戏称这是“史上最碉堡的地理题目”。这究竟是一张怎样的试卷？ Our China on July 13, when 22)（Reporter XiaoZiQi reporter KangYanFang apprentice）To learn geography is for the sake of what？Rich knowledge？Facilitate tourism？These answers are weak burst！12 evening，the“Wei fairy”In the blog has posted a junior high school geography exam screenshots of the subject，By 13, when the draw more than 600 that 23 net friend forwarding，Internet users in the forward more than badinage，Calls this is“In the history of the bunker geographical subject”。Whether it is a what kind of exam？

　　 网友讲述： 这道题“碉堡”了！ Net friend tells： The problem“bunker”the！

　　“学好地理，是为了更好地？ A、当大官 B、赚大钱 C、让父母高兴 D、生活。” “To learn geography，Is to better？ A、When big officer B、Make a lot of money C、Let parents happy D、life。”

　　这是一道单项选择题，题目要求“只有一个是正确选项”。 This is a single choice questions，The topic request“Only one is right choice”。

　　12日晚，有着这样一道被网友称为最“碉堡”地理题目的“2011年重庆市南开中学初2012级初二地理结业考试试卷”图片迅速在微博走红。这条发于7月12日晚上22点30分的微博，在短短一天内，转发量达到了500多次，评论量近百条，不少网友认为这应该是一张PS出来搞笑的假图。 12 evening，With such a net friend was called the most“bunker”Geographical subject“2011 in chongqing in the early nankai senior school level 2012 second completion examination papers geography”Picture in micro bo popular quickly。This article hair on July 12, 22:30 points of the night the Po，In just a day，Forwarding quantity achieved 500 times，Review article is nearly，Not a few net friend think this should be a PS out funny fake figure。

　　到底是真是假？今日中午，记者联系上最初发微博的网友“猥仙”，这名叫董浩的男孩是南开中学高2012届的毕业生。董浩称，这张截图是他在同学空间里看到的，“听说是我们学校的地理老师王磊（化名）出的，觉得很有意思，就传上来了。”董浩说，在他看来，这道题目出的很好，“很积极很正面，当然，确实也‘碉堡’了！” Is it true or not？Today at noon，When contacted FaWei bo's first users“Wei fairy”，This is the boy named 8 nankai senior school high of 2012 graduates。8 say，This screenshot is his students to see in space，“Heard that is our school of the geography teacher wang lei（aliases）Out of the，Feel very interesting，It is sent up the。”8 said，In his view，The problem of a well，“Very positive very positive，Of course，did‘bunker’the！”

　　 记者采访： 出题老师称六年都用该题考学生 来自现实生活的教育才最深刻 Reporters for the： Set the teacher say six years with this problem all test students from real life education is the most profound

　　为了证实真假，记者查询到南开中学电话，从中午一直拨打到下午16点，始终无人接听。随后，记者通过其他渠道联系上南开中学负责宣传的党办一文姓负责人，该负责人称自己在外出差，让记者联系另一位负责宣传的徐老师。而徐老师在听说记者来意后表示自己也在外出差，不了解情况。随后，记者按徐指引拨打了南开中学教务处电话，也一直无人接听。而多方打听来的南开中学田校长手机也一直处于呼叫转移状态。最后，记者通过几个小时的多方打听，终于在18点辗转联系上重庆南开中学地理老师王磊。 In order to prove true and false，Reporter inquires nankai senior school to phone，From noon to 16 points have been calling in the afternoon，Always no one answer。then，Reporters through the other channels on contact nankai senior school responsible for the DangBan are surname of propaganda，The person responsible for traveling，Let reporters contact another publicity of xu teacher。And xu teacher in heard that the reporter said after brief himself out on business，Don't know。then，According to the reporter xu guidelines call the nankai senior school office phone，Also have been went unanswered。Many find the nankai senior school principal field mobile phone has been call forwarding state。finally，Reporters through the several hours of various about，Finally in the 18 points in contact chongqing nankai senior school geography teacher wang lei。

　　王老师声音听上去并不年轻，他坦言题目正是自己所出：“从2006年新教材改革后开始至今，每年的初二地理结业考试都有这道题，许多学生答过这题。这道题是我原创，甚至可以说是全国首创。” Teacher wang voice sounds not young，He said it was his own out questions：“From 2006 years after the reform since the start of the new teaching material，The second year geography certificate all have the problem，Many students answer the question。This problem is my original，Even is the initiative。”

　　说起出这道题的缘由，王磊表示应该从地理学科的社会地位说起。“前些年，国家教育部取消了高考的地理科目，我觉得我们应该反思，是地理教程落后于学生的现实生活和社会需要，还是我们的地理教育不适合国家发展的需要？” Speaking of out the problem why，Wang lei said should be from the geography of social status。“Before some year，National ministry of education of the university entrance exam cancelled geographical subject，I think we should reflect on，Is the geographical tutorial student behind real life and social needs，The geographical education or are we not suitable for the need of our country's development？”

　　“学习地理的目的是什么，这是学生首先必须了解的。我是想让地理更贴近生活，贴近实际。”王磊说，其实题目中的四个选项都有一定合理性，但99%的学生都能选择出最具合理性的答案：为了生活。 “What is the purpose of the study geography，This is the student must first understand。I want to let the geography more close to the life，Close to actual。”Wang lei said，In fact in the topic four options has certain rationality，But 99% of the students can choose the most reasonable answer：In order to live。

　　至于为什么出这四个选项，王磊有自己的看法。“有些学生学习确实是为了父母开心，有些是看到社会上大家都奔金钱，还有些当然是看到现在人人都想当官的社会风气。”王磊说，做过这道题的学生都认为出得很好，让人印象深刻，“课堂上的公式化教育学生不一定接受，来自现实生活的教育才是最深刻的。”当然，王磊表示，这道题到底好不好并不是由自己说了算，还是由学生、家长和社会来评价。 As for why out the four options，WangLeiYou of their views。“Some students learning really is for my parents happy，Some see the society all rush of money，Some, of course, is now everyone wants to see the social atmosphere of officialdom。”Wang lei said，Had this problem is the students think out very well，Impressive，“In the classroom the formulation education students may not accept，From real life education is the most profound。”Of course，Wang lei said，This problem is really good and not by his word，Or by the students、Parents and society to evaluation。

　　 学校：老师的想法不代表学校 The school：The teacher ideas do not represent school

　　“我们不清楚情况，所以对于网友的议论也无法回应。”南开中学党办文姓负责人表示对这件事一无所知，不好回应。 “We don't know，So for the net friend talk also can't respond。”Last name DangBan nankai senior school, head says know nothing about it，Bad response。

　　“现在学校放假，我也在外出差，学校领导都在外地培训，无法联系上。”文老师说，不管大家认为这道题是好是坏，每个人都有自己的想法，每个人思考问题的方式都不同，网友愿意怎样看待是网友的事，学校对此无法给出回应，但“题目怎么出只是老师自己的想法，并不代表学校。” “Now a school holiday，I will on business outside，School leaders all over the field training，Can't contact。”Wen teacher said，Whether you think the problem is good is bad，Everyone has their own opinion，Everyone thought the way different problems，Net friend would like to see is how the net friend，This school is unable to provide response，but“Topic how only is the teacher himself thought，Doesn't mean the school。”

　　 学生：这样的考题挺好的 students：Such examination questions is pretty good

　　据最初发微博的学生董浩介绍，这道地理题目南开中学的许多学生都知道，“学习地理是为了更好地生活”也是王磊老师一直强调的观点。 According to initial FaWei bo's introduced 8 students，This way the geographical subject of nankai senior school students knew that many，“In order to study geography is a better life”Teacher wang lei is always emphasized that point of view。

　　做过这道题的南开中学初二学生张露（化名）称，她当时选的D选项“学好地理是为了更好的生活”，因为老师在课堂上这样讲过，而且之前做练习题的时候也做过，她自己也确实认为，学好地理不是为了当官、赚钱或者父母高兴，而是为了更好的生活。 Did the problem of the second ZhangLou nankai senior school students（aliases）says，She was chosen D options“To learn geography is to a better life”，Because in class the teacher speak thus，And do exercises before also do，She really think，To learn geography is not to be officer、Make money or parents happy，But to a better life。

　　张露说，当时看到这个题目她挺高兴的，因为简单，一看就不会丢分。据张露透露，她很多同学都觉得这个题目挺好的，本来考试很紧张，后来看到第一个考题这么简单，心情一下就很轻松了。 ZhangLou said，When read the title she very happy，For simple，A look at won't lose points。According to ZhangLou revealed，She many students feel this topic is pretty good，The exam was very nervous，Then saw the first examination questions so simple，The mood is very easy。

　　“老师有自己的想法，我觉得很好。”巴蜀中学高二学生郭秋来在看到该微博后认为，现在有些老师只知道照本宣科，有时候创新也会让学生加深对科目的兴趣。“这个题目其实也是送分题，只不过是为了强化学生学习地理的目的，不用大惊小怪。” “The teacher has a mind of its own，I feel very good。”Bashu middle school school students GuoQiuLai see the micro bo in that，Now some teachers only know from the book，Sometimes innovation also would allow students to deepen our understanding of the subjects of interest。“This subject is actually send points problem，In order to strengthen the students' learning is only the purpose of geography，Don't make a fuss。”

　　同样，重庆第十八中学的初中学生李峰也认为，这道题跟以往的考试题目差别很大。“我觉得这种题目多好的，简单明了，学生不会答错，如果是我，我也喜欢这种题。”李峰说，考题不一定要太难，只要达到老师想达到的目的就行。 The same，Chongqing first ShiBaZhong school students learn LiFeng also think，The problem with previous exam questions the difference is very big。“I think this topic much good，Simple and clear，Students will never answer wrong，If I，I also like this kind of problem。”LiFeng said，Examination questions doesn't have to be too difficult，As long as to the teacher wants to achieve purpose will do。

　　 其他地理老师：这不是地理题，任何一个学科都能出 Other the geography teacher：This is not the geographical problem，Any one discipline can be out

　　求精中学教地理的孙老师看到这个考题后认为，这不是一道地理题，换到任何一个科目的考试，都可以出这样一道题。 Refinement taught secondary school geography teacher to see the sun that the examination questions，This is not a geographic problem，To change any one course exam，Can such a question。

　　孙老师称，很明显，出题这位老师的本意是让同学们知道，学好地理是为了更好的生活，在孙老师的地理课上，她也是这样教学生的：学好地理是为了让自己的知识更丰富、生活更丰富。 The teacher said he，obviously，Set the teacher is meant to let students know，To learn geography is to a better life，The teacher in the sun geography class，She is also such teaching students：To learn geography is to let oneself knowledge more abundant、Life more rich。

　　不过孙老师称，如果是她来出题，她不会这样出，因为这个题目跟地理学本身没什么关系，而且任何一个学科都可以出这样一道题，这属于政治学科、价值观教育的范畴。 But he said the teacher，If she is set to，She wouldn't be so out，Because the subject has nothing to with geography itself，And any one discipline can be such a question，It belongs to the political discipline、Values education category。

　　 教育学专家：题目可以打破传统 但不宜脱离学科本身 Education experts：The topic can break traditional but unfavorable from subject itself

　　重庆市教育科学研究院高级教师张弘称，从教育学来看，南开中学的这道题打破了传统的思维模式，有点剑走偏锋，也比较贴近生活，所以才会在网络上很火。 Chongqing institute of advanced education science teacher ZhangHong says，From education to see，Nankai senior school of this problem is to break the traditional thinking mode，A little sword go hail，Is close to the life，So he just on the network is fire。

　　但是张弘称，考试出题有两个基本的原则，一个是效度，即出这道题要达到的效果，还有一个是信度，即考试题目要符合科学。而这道题，跟地理学本身关系不大，谈不上好有信度。从效度上讲，也起不到好大个效果。 But ZhangHong says，The questions on the exam, there are two basic principles，One is the validity，That is out the problem to the effect，Another is a reliability，That is the examination questions to comply with science。And the problem，Geography itself with the concern is not big，No good faith degrees。From the validity speak，Also not a very big effect。

　　张弘称，考题可以打破传统，可以变换花样，出得生动活泼有趣一点，这些创新值得鼓励，但最好不要脱离学科本身，否则就是去了学科教育的意义。 ZhangHong says，Examination questions can break traditional，Can vary，The lively and lively and interesting point，These innovation should be encouraged，But had better not from subject itself，Otherwise, it is subject to the education significance。

　　 网友观点 The view

　　 正方：新课标与时俱进了 square：The new standard of advancing with The Times

　　黄煌Heddy ：南开的老师真是千年亮，一道地理题折射出了政治，经济与伦理，但不管选什么都是为了更好的生活！ HuangHuang Heddy ：The teacher was one thousand years of nankai light，A geography questions reflected political，Economic and ethical，But no matter what all is for the sake of better life！

　　喜欢睡觉的懒猫猫：强悍的南开！学好地理先树立好人生观，这其实也是一道哲学题，果然体现了新课标与时俱进的思想。 Like to sleep lazy cat cat：Violent of nankai！To learn geography to set up good outlook on life，It is also a question of philosophy，It reflects the new standard of the thought of keeping pace with The Times。

　　二娃的春天：我觉得每个选项都是正确答案，学好地理是为了父母开心，父母开心了就可以给个官做，有官做了就可以赚大钱，赚大钱了就更好地生活！ 2 her spring：I think each option is the correct answer，To learn geography is for my parents happy，Parents happy can give a officer，Have the officer could make a lot of money，Make a lot of money for a better life！

　　 反方：四个答案都不对咋办？ opposition：Four of the answers is correct to do？

　　小罗强子：南开的教育水平就这样呀？这就是重点中学的题目？ Ronaldinho hadronic：Education level of nankai university so ah？This is the subject of the key middle school？

　　从不流口水：如果这是真的，只能说这是典型的老师强暴学生想法的行为，这种水平让我想骂人。 Never mouth water：If this is true，Can only say this is typical of the teacher violence behavior of students ideas，This kind of level makes me want to call names。

　　柴非非：我觉得答案都不好，这种题怎么能拿来当考试题目。我觉得学好地理是为了逃避这种弱智老师。 ChaiFeiFei：I think the answer is bad，How can the subject for the examination questions。I think to learn geography to escape the weak-minded teacher。

　　 调查：学生赞同多 成人不接受 survey：The students agree with many adults don't accept

　　南开中学的这道地理考题今日红透了网络，转载和评论众多。到底该不该在中学生的地理考卷上出这样一道题？ The way of nankai senior school geography examination questions today through the red network，Reproduced and comment on the many。What shouldn't be on the high school students of geography exam such a question？

　　记者通过随机调查、电话采访等方式，调查了30位市民，其中包括10多位中学生。受访者中，大部分学生都选择了“应该，出题老师很有创意，很贴近生活”，而受访的成人多选择“不应该，出这种题不妥，有点误导学生的价值取向”。 Reporters through the random survey、Phone interviews, a way，The survey 30 citizen，Including more than 10 middle school students。respondents，Most of the students chose“should，The teacher set very creative，Very close to the life”，And the surveyed adults more choice“Should not，Out of this question wrong，A little misleading the value orientation of the students”。

　　选择“应该”选项的巴蜀中学学生张某称，虽然有人觉得这个考题不好，但他觉得挺好的，不生涩，很简单明了，通过很通俗、很生活化的方式让大家会认真去思考学习这门学科的意义。否则，有的学科可能学完了最后也丢完了，自始至终从没想过学了有啥用，为啥要去学。 choose“should”The middle school students zhang mou by our options says，Although some think the examination questions is not good，But he think it is good，Don't crude，Very simple and clear，Through the very popular、Life is the way you will seriously to think about the significance of studying the discipline。otherwise，Some discipline may be learned last also lost out，From beginning to end have never wanted to learn the useful at all，Is what want to learn。

　　选择“不应该”选项的市民陈小姐表示，她最开始以为这是网友的一个恶搞，没想到是真的出现在了初中生的考卷上，“当大官、赚大钱，这都是些什么价值观啊，小孩子不都被误导了吗？” choose“Should not”Chen said the public option，Her most began to think this is one of the stories，Thought is really in the junior high school students' test paper，“When big officer、Make a lot of money，What are all those values，The children do not have been misled？”

　　选择“不应该”选项的邓先生称，在他看来，这个老师的出题意图很好，是想引导孩子们正确的价值观，不要去追求“当大官、挣大钱”，但可以换个说法或方式，现在这样出题法，有些太粗糙了，让人觉得出题老师太随意，不够认真。 choose“Should not”The options in deng says，In his view，This teacher sets the topic the intention is very good，Is to guide the children the right values，Not to pursue“When big officer、Earn big money”，But can change a statement or way，So now the questions on the law，Some are too rough，Let a person feel the questions on the teacher too casual，Not seriously enough。