原标题：违反纪律罚款2元？学生吐槽，老师否认 Original title:Violation of discipline fined $2?Students vomit tank,The teacher deny

　　律师：老师罚款于法无据；多位网友称当年有被罚经历，老师拿了罚款做奖励 lawyer:The teacher in a fine not law-based;Many netizens say was sent by experience,The teacher took a fine do reward

　　本报记者刘颖 实习生高思 长沙报道

Our reporter LiuYing interns high thought changsha report

　　9月17日，晨报QQ800096360一位网友表示，自己正在宁乡某中学读初三，去年开始班上就立了条规矩，凡是迟到或者违反课堂纪律一律罚款2元。这位网友想问：“老师罚款合理吗？”

On September 17,The morning paper QQ800096360 a net friend said,He is a middle school ningxiang read grade,Last year he instituted the rule in the class,Those who be late or in violation of discipline in the class will be fined $2.The net friend want to ask:"The teacher a fine reasonable?"

　　违反纪律罚款2元？老师否认 Violation of discipline fined $2?The teacher deny

　　这位不愿透露姓名的网友介绍，罚款会通过奖励返还给学生，考试好或者其他方面获奖都能获得奖励。虽然这笔钱最后用在了学生身上，但他仍然觉得，老师无权对学生罚款。对于这名网友的报料，其班主任老师称：“我们没有罚款，只有同学按自愿原则缴纳的班费。”对于违反纪律罚2元一事，该老师表示绝无此事，称班上确实有奖励措施，但都是通过班费来运转。“给每个同学都有打分，表现好加分，表现不好扣分，然后根据综合分数做出相应奖励。”记者联系到学校相关负责人，对方称没听过“罚款”一事。“首先学校肯定不会做这种规定，而且我们也反对老师罚款。”

The anonymity of the net friend is introduced,A fine will be through the reward returned to the student,The exam good or other aspects winning can reap the rewards.Although the money is finally used in the student body,But he still felt that,The teacher has no right to a fine for students.For the name of the net friend writer,The teacher in charge teacher says:"We don't have a fine,Only students according to the principle of voluntary pay expense."For violation of discipline penalty about $2,The teacher said no matter,Say class do have incentives,But it is through the expense to operate."Give each student has marking,Performance good points,Bad marks,Then according to the comprehensive score makes the corresponding reward."Reporters linked to the relevant person in charge of the school,The other party say not heard"fine"about."The first school won't do this kind of regulation,And we are opposed to a fine teacher."

　　湖南万和联合律师事务所李健律师表示，老师罚款的做法“合理不合法”。李健表示，《中华人民共和国教师法》规定老师有权利和义务对学生进行管教和约束，指导他们健康成长，但是并没赋予老师经济处罚权、体罚权等过激权利，因此罚款于法无据。

Hunan and joint law firm lawyers said li,The teacher a fine practice"Reasonable illegal".Li said,[Law of the People's Republic of China]Provisions teacher has the right and obligation to undertake to the student discipline and restraint,Guide them to grow up healthily,But he did not give the teacher economic power/The corporal punishment rights ultra rights,So in a fine not law-based.

　　网友晒上学罚款经历 Net friend sun fine school experience

　　虽然罚款一事没有得到学校确认，但不少网友都表示自己上学时曾有类似经历。网友“小丸子”通过晨报QQ800096360说，自己初中时就是班上的“纪委”，班主任定好罚款标准和范围，她负责监督和收钱，每月罚款所得都用于班上活动和购买奖品等。最少罚0.5元，最多的也罚过10元，但那种情况特别少。“小丸子”说，当时自己这个工作得罪了不少同学。“现在回想，我觉得老师罚款是不对的，他们没有这个权利，但在当时我们都很单纯，从没想过这个问题。”

Although the school fine didn't get confirmation,But many net friends all say his school had similar experience.Net friend"Small balls"Through the morning paper QQ800096360 said,His junior high school is the class"Discipline inspection commission",The teacher in charge fines set standard and scope,She is responsible for supervision and money,A fine monthly income to the class activities and buy prizes, etc.At least penalty 0.5 yuan,Most also fined $10,But that very little."Small balls"said,Oneself at that time the work have sinned against many schoolmates."Looking back now,I think the teacher a fine is wrong,They haven't the right,But this time we are all very simple,Never thought this problem."

　　长沙第一师范大四学生小阳也表示，自己在高中时遇到过类似情况。小阳当年觉得老师这样做并无不妥，只要遵规守纪，自然不会被罚。相反，有时考试还能拿到奖品，也就不会考虑那些被罚的同学心情。“迟到、早自习吃早餐都会被罚几块钱，但这样做违纪现象确实少了。”小阳说，班主任都会把罚款用来奖励考试优秀的学生，大部分同学都是认可的。

Changsha first normal senior student small Yang also said,In his high school meet a similar situation.Small Yang when think the teacher to do so there is nothing wrong,As long as follow rules discipline,Nature will not be fined.instead,Sometimes the exam and can get prizes,Won't consider those who be fined classmates mood."late/During morning independent study to eat breakfast will be fined a few dollars,But do this discipline phenomenon do less."Small Yang said,The teacher in charge will be fine to be used for awarding prizes to the exam excellent students,Most students are recognized.

　　[晨报QQ800096360互动]

[the morning paper QQ800096360 interaction]

　　针对罚钱做成奖励是否合理，17日很多网友通过晨报QQ800096360评论：

To make a money award is reasonable,17 many users through the morning paper QQ800096360 comments:

　　“空城 落寂”：我读初中的时候我们组每个星期倒数第一，每人每星期2元罚款，倒数第二小组每人每星期1元，我从初一到初三只怕罚了一百多！

"Empty city fall silence":I read junior high school of time our group every week the last one,Each person every week 2 yuan a fine,Penultimate team every week 1 yuan per person,I'm from first to third day nothing is sent more than one hundred!

　　“吃猫的竹子”：初中时，班主任老师定的规矩，迟到的罚扫厕所，男的扫女厕所，女的扫男厕所。自此，无一人敢迟到。

"Eat cat of bamboo":Junior high school,The teacher in charge teacher set rules,Late penalty and toilet,Male and female toilet,Woman and man's room.Since then,No one dare to be late.

　　“眼镜蛇”：我孩子上周拿回一包饼干，她说是一同学家长买的。因为那同学在教室违规吃饼干，老师要求其家长给班上每个同学买一包同样的饼干。

"cobra":My child last week take back a packet of biscuits,She said that a classmate parents buy.Because the students in the classroom illegal to eat cookies,The teacher asked their parents to everyone in the class students buy a pack of the same biscuits.

　　整理/记者刘颖

Finishing/reporter LiuYing