学生反映，英语小测标准被老师划为60分-90分几个等级，考试进步就奖励现金，退步就扣钱，迟到旷课也要“罚款”，没做作业就要给全班买笔。有的同学每天要被罚四五元，还有同学“欠费”。

学生反映,English test standard is divided into 60 points - 90 points by the teacher,Cash rewards the test progress,Setbacks will deduct money,Late is absent from school"A fine",Didn't do your homework is going to buy a pen to the class.Some students will be fined four or five dollars per day,And my classmates"Owe fee".

“个人尝试” "People try to"

　　该英语老师称，她尝试这种办法，只是希望能调动孩子们的学习积极性，并已取得一定效果，“多数同学表示认可”。用来奖罚的那些钱，她都不会经手，而是交给科代表登记执行

该英语The teacher称,Her to try this way,Just want to arouse the learning enthusiasm of the children,And has achieved a certain effect,"Most students said".Used for rewards and punishment of the money,She won't be handled,But to the families and representatives registration is carried out

事件缘起 Of events

将学生划分标准 退步罚钱进步领钱 Will be back by the standard of students progress to bring money

　　厦门十中初三10班学生晓楠（化名）说，英语每天早上都有一个小测，内容包括单词、词组以及句子等。最近，英语老师刘老师按照学习成绩，把同学们划分为几个标准:小组长90分，一些同学80分，最低的同学被定在60分。刘老师规定:每个同学根据自己的分数标准，超过了就奖钱，达不到就要扣钱。一个单词、词组一般是5分，句子是10分。也就是说，90分标准线的同学，只要错了2个单词或者1个句子以上，就要罚钱，罚多少按照每个人的分数来定，一般差10分是扣1元，扣的钱交到英语科代表那里管理；当然，超过标准线的同学也有奖钱，一般也是超过10分奖励1元钱，也是到英语科代表处领取。

厦门十In the初三10班学生晓楠(Not his real name)said,In English there is a quiz in the morning,Including words/Phrases and sentences.recently,English teacher liu according to the grades,Divided the students into several standard: the heads of 90 points,Some students of 80 points,最低的同学被定In the60分.Liu regulation: every students according to their own standard scores,Over the prize money,Reach will be buckle money.A word/Phrases usually 5 points,Sentence is 10 points.That is to say,90 line of classmates,As long as the wrong more than two words or a sentence,Will be fined,How much penalty according to everyone's score,Typically 10 points are deducted 1 yuan,Buckles money making English families represent management there;Of course,,More than standard classmates prize money,Is generally more than 10 points reward 1 yuan,Also to the English branch representative office to receive.

　　“我们班有的同学每天就要被罚四五元，罚一两元的也不少。”晓楠说，罚的总是比奖的多，所以就会有钱积攒下来，不管罚钱还是奖钱，“羊毛都是出在羊身上”。

"Some students in our class every day will be off four or five yuan,One or two dollars is a lot of."XiaoNan said,More is always better than prize,So will have money accumulated,Regardless of money or a prize money,"羊毛都是出In the羊身上".

　　该校初三9班学生晓媛（化名）表示，他们班的英语老师和10班的英语老师是同一位，因此班上也是实行这种办法。刘老师还强调，她讲过的题目，只要学生写错了，一分罚一元；然而，考好的同学奖励并不多。这种办法实行不久，该班级的英语科代表已经“收入”100元左右，还有同学欠款。

该校初三9班学生晓媛(Not his real name)said,Their English teacher and 10 class English teacher is the same,Therefore also adopted this method in the class.Liu also stressed that,She talked about the topic,As long as the student write is wrong,A points penalty is one yuan;however,Test good classmate reward is not much.The way to implement soon,In charge of English in the class has already"income"100 yuan or so,Balance and classmates.

　　“老师说，期末的时候，考试进步的学生就奖励现金，剩下来的当班费。”初三9班学生晓娟（化名）说。

"The teacher said,At the end of time,Get a cash reward in my progress of students,The rest when class expense."XiaoJuan class 9 grade 3 students(Not his real name)said.

学生不满 Dissatisfaction with the students

老师“以罚代教” 迟到旷课都要“罚款” The teacher"Penalty for teach" Truancy is being late"A fine"

　　“这种奖惩方式，我们班的确有很多同学不能理解。”晓娟说，刘老师平常比较严格，虽然这么做是为了激励学生提高成绩，而且老师自己也没经手那些钱，但是这种方式还是引起不少同学的不满。

"This way of rewards and punishments,There are many students in our class can't understand."XiaoJuan said,Liu usually more strictly,Although doing so is to encourage students to improve performance,And the teacher didn't also handles the money,But this way is caused a lot of classmates.

　　晓楠也认为，这不是钱多钱少的问题，初三学生都没有经济来源，不是拿家长的钱，就是拿自己吃饭的生活费，这种奖罚现金的做法不是好现象，更像是一种“以罚代教”的行为。

晓楠也认为,It's not a question of money less money,Grade students have no economy source,Not take parents money,Is eat your cost of living,This kind of cash rewards and punishment is not a good phenomenon,More like a"Penalty for teach"The behavior of the.

　　对该老师的印象，晓楠表示，刘老师的确是上课上得好，写过的一些论文还获过奖，证书也给学生看过。但是，对于该老师的一些做法，晓楠还是不大认同:初二时，也是这位老师在班上实行了“买笔办法”。学生没做作业就要买笔，一下子就要买几十根，然后发给全班同学。“其实我们收到笔时也不会太开心，毕竟羊毛出在羊身上。”晓楠说。

对该The teacher的印象,XiaoNan said,Liu is really well on school,Written some papers also won the lottery,Certificate also for students.but,For some of the teacher's approach,XiaoNan still not agree: the second day,也是这位The teacherIn the班上实行了"Buy a pen to".Students do homework didn't want to buy a pen,Suddenly want to buy dozens of root,And then sent to the class."In fact when we receive the pen also won't be happy,毕竟羊毛出In the羊身上."XiaoNan said.

　　记者了解到，刘老师还是初三9班的班主任。 “我们班除了英语小测，迟到什么的也要罚钱。迟到罚5元，旷课一节罚10元，阅读没用红笔罚一元，没画线也罚一元。”晓媛说。

记者了解到,Mr Liu is the head teacher of class 9 grade 3. "In addition to our class English quiz,Late for what also want sent money.Late for 5 yuan,Truancy section 10 yuan,Reading useless red pen fined one yuan,No line drawing also fined one yuan."XiaoYuan said.

老师回应 The teacher responded

这种奖惩“尝试” 只为提高学生成绩 This kind of rewards and punishments"Try to" To improve student performance

　　昨日下午，记者致电刘老师，反馈了学生的意见。“有些孩子的学习真是太被动了，我只是想方设法地提高他们的成绩。”刘老师说，她带的班级虽然是普通班，但通过师生一起努力，照样能考到年段第一。针对有些学生被动学习的情况，她尝试着采用奖罚办法，希望能够调动学生的学习积极性。她制定的分数标准因人而异，但不是一成不变的，刚开始从30分到80分都有，后来有学生成绩提高了，她也相应提高标准，小组长轻易就能达到80分了，她就提高到了90分。

昨日下午,Reporters call liu,Feedback the views of the students."Some children learn is too passive,I'm just trying to improve their grades."Liu said,She took the class although it is a regular class,But by teachers and students work together,Can test all the same to the period of the first year.In the presence of some of the students' passive learning,She tried to use rewards and punishment measures,Hope to be able to mobilize the study enthusiasm of students.She set score standards vary from person to person,But it's not set in stone,Beginning from 30 to 80 points,Then, to improve student performance,She also raise standards accordingly,The leader can easily reach 80 points,She was increased to 90 points.

　　刘老师表示，在她看来，她从元旦尝试这种办法以来，取得了一定的效果，“9班有一个学生，以前英语考到20分以下，后来有一次竟然考了90几分，他到科代表那里领奖金时也很高兴”。刘老师还举了10班一个同学的例子，这个办法实行后，该同学的英语成绩提高到90几分，几乎每天都能拿奖金。而且，从元旦前后的班级成绩对比来看，总体成绩也是有所提高。刘老师认为，这个办法还是得到大多数同学认可的。

刘The teachersaid,In the她看来,She since New Year's day to try this way,Some results have been achieved,"There are one of the students in 9 class,Below 20 points before her English test,And then one time should take an examination of 90 a few minutes,When he gets his bonus to the families and representatives are also very happy".Liu also cited the example of a 10 class,This method was implemented,The students English scores increased to 90,Almost every day can get bonus.and,From the class performance comparison before and after the New Year's day,Overall performance is also improved.Liu thinks,It is recognised by most students.

　　刘老师强调，这只是她个人想出来提高学生积极性的一种办法，她并没有插手钱的管理，并不能简单地说是“以罚代教”。不过，得知一些学生通过网络反对此事后，刘老师表示会进一步和学生沟通，出现反效果的话她不会继续坚持用这个办法，而是选择停止。

刘The teacher强调,This is just her personal think out a way to improve students' enthusiasm,She didn't hand in money management,Do not simply say yes"Penalty for teach".but,After learned that some of the students through the network against it,Mr Liu said it would further communication with students,Negative effects if she will not continue to insist on this way,But choose to stop.

　　昨日，记者没有联系上厦门十中的校领导，还没有听到他们关于此事的说法。本报将继续为您追踪报道。（记者 汪长福）

昨日,记者没有联系上厦门十In the的校领导,Haven't heard what they said about the matter.We will continue to track for you.(The reporter Wang Changfu)